The coffee shop is so crowded with kids on lunch break between classes. Funny calling them kids, when I moved here they were contemporaries. Now, crossing the streets by the college is an exercise in eye rolling frustration and dodging hipsters absorbed in their ethically dubious iPhones. Walking here was unexpectedly nerve wracking. I thought I was ready- prepared. I compartmentalized work and my relationship from this meeting. I arranged with my best friend to call halfway through lunch. i wore a dress that was simple but not overly flattering. I told him- actually I asked.
“Do you mind if I meet an old friend from college? I should tell you that we’ve been more than friends, and in the past he meant a lot to me.”
“Do what you want.”
Do what I want. I wanted to prove that I could move on. To reconnect and realize that the spark was just nostalgia, and that now I’m a
mature woman. And maybe, a tiny part of me wanted to see him. Ask how he was- if he had a girlfriend, or fiancé, or wife.
I wasn’t ready when I saw him. All of my planning and I walked out onto the street, fake pregnant belly in place- a basket on my arm and the perspiration of false labor in my arm pits. He glanced up and pointed at the phone-
“I was following you.”
My manager shoots me a look, clearly confirming that she will call security right here and now if I am unsafe. How to explain- can I explain?
“I need to change, I’ll meet you in a minute?” As we walk away I’m already assuring her that this was planned, just an old friend from college. Just a friend.
Who exactly am I trying to convince?
When I first saw him I thought that maybe I could leave it all behind. He’s not the way I remember- or maybe I’ve grown into myself. In the dressing room I wrap my hair in a kerchief and brush the powder off my neck. History problems. He doesn’t know that- it must be strange for him and yet it’s so normal to my existence.
Back out on the street and my confidence plummets. How is it that I can present a program to 50 people, I can cry or fake a contraction or answer questions about legal intricacies and yet all of a sudden my insides are writhing like I’m 18 all over again. Butterflies- is that what these are? It’s been so long I can’t tell.
He tells me he’s a Captain now. I can’t help it- I laugh and am filled with instant regret. I try to explain about calling him by one of Jane Austen’s invented names a million years ago, that that fictional person was also a captain. I’m making everything so much worse. My body tries to close the gap between us but I stay stubbornly two feet away on the sidewalk. I think if someone had a knife you could slice the tension in the space between us.
We order our coffees and lunches and find a seat. Why did I only get soup? I am never nervous about eating in front of the man I’m dating- I don’t much care what he thinks of me. For some reason though, in this moment I want to be attractive. Am I trying to show him what he missed? Prove that I’m more a woman than I was before? I’m leaning in across the table and my fingers are making slow rings around the neck of my Nantucket Nectar. I realize that I want the bottle to be his lips. I don’t stop.
My phone buzzes as we eat our food.
“Are you ok? Do you need an out?”
“All good- thanks for checking!” I’m not all good. I’m writhing internally and my face is probably visibly flushing. We’re talking about everything- about nothing. I can’t tell you what were saying even as the words come out of my mouth. I’m drowning in blue eyes. You’d think I would have learned by now to bring a life jacket. My phone tells me it’s time to clock in and go back to work. I silence it, clock in, and keep sitting there. My afternoon is free and I don’t want this to end.
Finally I can’t avoid the fact that I am under the pretense of working today. We slide out and start the walk back to town, my feet wanting to drag a little with each step. As we get back to the Main Street I notice that I have closed the distance between us, and that I’m smiling all the way to my eyes. I haven’t smiled like that in years, it’s a concerted effort to stop but the streets have eyes here. Walking back to the office and I turn, not sure how to say goodbye. If this is the last time forever, there are so many things I want to say. I say
“The blacksmith is around the corner- let me know if you need help finding anything else in the city!”
I walk away, glancing back over my shoulder and seeing him disappear around the red kitchen building.
My dressing room is mercifully empty. I close the door and lean against it, sliding slowly down to rest on the floor. Am I breathing? I’m gasping. I haven’t felt like this in years. Not in a decade. I’m talking but it’s not a nonsensical babble, “oh my god- oh my god!” I fan myself with my hands, well aware that I have maybe ten minutes to pull myself together before someone comes back to the room. I try to push it back into its compartment, the neat box I’ve constructed in my mind. The lid won’t fit.
In the course of an hour, my entire world had gone off center. Someone pulled the covers off and woke me up like my father used to do when I was late for school. Now I’m looking at my life from outside, watching myself settle with being content. Watching me give up on the only dream I ever had- falling hopelessly in love.
But it’s not real. It can’t be. It was just lunch.
I stand and look at myself in the mirror. I’m still the same on the outside. If I ignore the fire in my chest, it will eventually extinguish. I lick my lips and taste the last of the lemon aid.
It’s too late. I took the apple and bit into it, and now for my sins I must live with the knowledge of my own naked emotions. It’s always been him. It’ll always be him.